On The Record
Registered Sex Offenders for Edgefield
PO Box 972
Dr. Skip Myers
State and Federal
Local Political Parties
Chamber of Commerce
The Jail Report
New York Times
New York Post
Los Angeles Times
past articles please visit our Archives
Upstate Deer Baiting Bill on Fast Track to Becoming Law
web posted February 2, 2013
GUEST OPINION - Alert for Hunters in Game
Zone 1 and 2. Bill S091 which will allow the shooting of deer over bait
in game zones 1 and 2 has passed the Senate and the Sub-committee of
the House. The Bill whizzed through the house with a 22-15 vote with 14
of the Aye votes cast being Lowstate or baiting influenced county
votes. The Bill passed the House sub-committee with a 3-1 vote with the
lone nay vote being from Rep. Shannon Riley from the Upstate. Even
lawmakers are stunned as to how fast this bill has moved through the
Senate and is moving through the House. Nothing usually given fair
consideration passes/ moves so expediently.
S091 has been sent to full committee of the House and may be voted on,
as early as, Tues Feb 5. If S091 passes the House committee it will
most likely become law.
If you are against this bill then contact your House Representative and
the members of the Agriculture, Natural Resources, and Environmental
Affairs Committee and ask them to kill this bill while it is still in
committee before it reaches the floor of the House. The link for the
committee members is below. Make sure you also contact the Low State
members voting, their votes are crucial and they need to hear from you,
the Upstate hunter, since technically they have no dog in the fight.
Please pass this information on to your Upstate hunting buddies and
friends. It is URGENT! http://www.scstatehouse.gov/committeeinfo/houseagri.php
A little history as to how S091 was birthed:
Within the last couple of hunting season a hunter was caught hunting
deer over bait and charged as such based on the current law in the
books. The hunter took the case to the magistrate in the area, I would
think which involved connections, and the case was dismissed. The case
was appealed according to the existing wildlife laws on the books. The
offender retained a slick lawyer and the ruling by the magistrate was
Long story short, the South Carolina Attorney General ruled the
existing law on the books could not uphold in a court of law. The law
reads as follows: July 2012 regulations, pg 47- “In game zones 1 and
2...... it is unlawful to bait for deer.” The S.C. Attorney General
ruled that the law stated no baiting for deer not that you could not
shoot deer over bait.
Please give me a break, I know the intention of that law, you know the
intention of that law, and the violator knew the intention of that law.
Now whether you choose to be a law abiding citizen or not that is a
separate issue. Based on the ruling above, SCDNR Law Enforcement
Officers were instructed to refrain from writing citations for baiting
in game zones 1 and 2. That leads us to Bill S091.
I was asked recently, at the House Sub-Committee meeting, why I oppose
baiting as an outdoorsman. Well bear with me---- here goes:
1) Not hunting over bait is my hunting heritage and I would like to see
that type of hunting preserved in the Upstate. I am not judging others
that bait or want to bait, just for me, I don't like sitting on a pile
of corn. About twenty years ago I did bait hunt on a few Lowstate
invites, it just was not for me. I realize baiting is not the magic fix
to see or kill deer but I feel it gives the hunter an unfair advantage.
I really don't care what the low state does, we all have an opinion or
roots and these are mine.
2) Not judging but I honestly don't think killing deer over bait is
fair pursuit of game. I am just common Joe but honestly I have had my
eyes opened to a few hunting/ gun owning facts the last few weeks. It
has been statistically proven that if a hunter asks for permission to
hunt an owner’s land, of the ones that grant permission, 80% will allow
hunting on their property only if fair chase and pursuit of game is
involved. Sitting on a corn pile or bait does not represent fair chase
in the eyes of most non-hunting land owner’s .The fact is, with gun
ownership issues as they are the non-hunter but pro gun owners opinion
does matter. And, as stated above, 80% don't see baiting as fair
3) From an economic stand point, I just can't afford it. So folks say
don't do it if it passes. Well I know for a fact, from my Lowstate
buddies, to keep deer on my 50 hunting acres, if my neighbors bait I
will have to defense bait. I just don't have the $$$ to do it. Also if
S091 passes expect your hunting lease price in the Upstate to increase
drastically. Why, because of an influx of hunters from other areas
bidding on your lease since they can now go the easy route of baiting.
4) Folks have said give me biological proof of the harm of baiting or I
want it because the Lowstate has it. In the 1998 July/ August edition
of turkey talk Dr. James Earl Kennamer wrote an article titled "Deer
Corn Can Harm Wild Turkeys" The article is about aflatoxin poisoning
transmitted through the feeding of deer corn. Lab studies show it is
real. The studies showed negative effects on quail chicks and young
turkeys. It also references poisoning confirmed cases of geese and
ducks. The study states, “samples were taken from 39 food bins in SC
and NC, in 51% of those samples poisoning levels were present..... 10%
had extremely high levels of aflatoxin.” Why take the chance with our
wildlife resources, you can harvest plenty of deer in the upstate
5) An executive from Quality Deer Management (QDM) was at the
sub-committee meeting. He referenced cases where deer diseases have
been spread in bait piles in other states. He stated, “Yes deer wasting
disease is still a few states away but it is surely a matter of time
before a case shows up in South Carolina.” Again why take the chance to
harvest a deer on corn you can already harvest in the upstate without
corn? WHY INVITE THE PLAGUE INSIDE YOUR HOUSE IF YOU DON”T HAVE IT?
6)"They do it in the Lowstate and other counties so I want to do it
also" I/we have heard it over and over. An extreme rebuttal but, pot is
legal in California, that doesn’t mean I think it is right or for that
matter want it legal in SC! Yes, I know, extreme so fire away. But my
point is, the Lowstate and Upstate are different diverse regions of the
state with wildlife needs and hunting heritage differing. Always has
been different, always will be different. Just because they have it
DOWN THERE, doesn’t necessarily make it right for UP HERE. That is why
you have game zones, different limits, and different seasons.
South Carolina Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) has not and can
not come out and support any bill or legislation of this nature, pro or
con, for obvious reasons. SCDNR just wants a bill they can enforce. But
my understanding is the DNR Board is against baiting in the Upstate.
Reference a Feb 2012 vote online. I believe only one vote for baiting
in the upstate was cast.
Let's amend the old law, give DNR something a lawyer can't
intentionally put in shambles, and have no shooting of deer over bait
in the Upstate.
It has been said, talk on the street, as long as a year ago that
shooting deer over bait in the Upsate is a done deal and it will be
passed as law. I guess the point is, this thing has been ram rodded,
and I don’t like to see issues shoved down my or the voting publics
In closing I would like to say, the Senator sponsoring the bill opened
the meeting by stating, “The Jeannie is out of the bottle- we can not
turn back, we need to pass this bill.” You see it has been called a
done deal, the passing of S091, and non-baiter's opinions are not
supposed to matter. As I addressed the committee I told them, “The
Jeannie is not yet out of the bottle, the cork has just been removed.
You have the opportunity and should put the cork back in the bottle.
Draft amendments to the existing laws that prohibit the shooting of
deer over bait in the Upstate and leave our Upstate hunting tradition
as it is.
P.S. Hunter if you think this bill is just about baiting for deer, you
better reconsider or shall I say wake up! The ramifications of S091 go
far deeper than the baiting of deer. With gun control issues as they
are now, the lobbyist for gun control are looking for any reason(s) to
take your firearms. These will most likely start with the hunter, and a
Bill as in S091, which involves no fair chase of game in the
non-hunters eyes just cracks the door a little wider for them to enter.
Concerned Game Zone 1 and 2 Hunter
© Copyright 2012 - 2013 All material is property of
Edgefield Daily and/or parent company ECL and
cannot be reproduced,
redistributed without expressed written permission.